Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Newell v. Whitcher (1880)


a.       Facts- P, blind music teacher for D, was sleeping overnight in D’s house. D entered the room P was sleeping in, and “made repeated and persistent solicitations to her for sexual intimacy, which she repelled”. P sued D to recover for the sickness and fright she claimed to have suffered as a result.
b.      Procedural History- Trial Ct entered judgment on jury verdict for P. D appealed
c.       Issue- Whether D’s actions constituted assault
d.      Holding- Yes, D’s actions did constitute assault
e.       Rule- All necessary requisites of assault were present: intent and action
f.       Rationale- D had the intent to offend P, and P had an apprehension of imminent offense

No comments:

Post a Comment